The dubious election
The Greek press is having a field day. “We failed, but vote for us again,” blared the banner headline on opposition-friendly daily Ta Nea. “Voluntary redundancy,” sniggered the similarly slanted Ethnos.
Prime Minister Kostas Karmanalis’ declaration of snap elections on September 2 hardly came as a surprise, though. Ever since he reshuffled his cabinet in January, many political commentators have opined that it was his battle formation for an attempt at a third term.
This was mainly because he purged the cabinet of anyone with a lingering connection to the Vatopaidi scandal, and ditched then-finance minister Yiorgos Alogoskoufis, who had associated himself (unforgivably, it turns out) with fiscal discipline.
The question was whether Karamanlis would hold the general election around Easter, or simultaneously with European Parliament elections in June.
The one scenario that was considered highly unlikely was that he would wait until now.
Opinion polls showed that voters would use the Europarliament election to lodge a protest vote, handing opposition socialists their first victory.
After that, the veneer of conservative invincibility would be gone forever, and a general election more likely to favour socialist leader Yiorgos Papandreou.
This is precisely what has happened. Pasok won 36.65 percent of the vote to conservative New Democracy’s 32.29 percent.
Pasok did not advance spectacularly compared to its 2004 result of 34 percent, but New Democracy did fall spectacularly from 43 percent.
The difference between the two was convincing enough to reverse the psychology of defeat within PASOK.
So the one scenario deemed undesirable for New Democracy is being carried out. Why?
One reason is that the government fell into Pasok’s trap.
Sensing the government’s fatigue, the socialists declared that they would trigger elections in March, when New Democracy needs bipartisan support to re-elect the president to a second term.
Karamanlis deemed that his government could not withstand the extended election period that would be created over the next six months.
It is worth remembering that Karamanlis is not a great parliamentary democrat. He declared snap elections in September 2007 because the independent money laundering authority was about to present a damning report to parliament’s ethics and transparency committee on a bond his finance minister issued in 2006.
In May this year he declared an end to the parliamentary session six weeks earlier than usual, to pre-empt discussion of other scandals PASOK was hoping the prosecutor would bring.
It was highly unlikely that Karamanlis and his ministers would have fared well during the next six months. PASOK would use every legislative debate to try them by popular vote.
A third reason for early elections is the economy. The most important piece of annual legislation is the budget. It is also constitutionally the first, due on the first Monday in October.
Karamanlis knows the 2010 budget will not be pretty. He would rather campaign for it than justify it as an incumbent.
There are those in New Democracy who believe that the government should have held the moral high ground of attempting to serve out its term rather than falling on its sword. But that presupposes defeat, and is merely a question of what style one wants to go out in.
The real question now is not whether Karamanlis procrastinated or jumped the gun. It is whether Greece can elect a government authorised to pull it out of recession.
There are serious reasons to doubt that it can. Pasok’s gains have, over the past five years, consistently lagged behind New Democracy’s losses.
What we have witnessed is not a classic swinging of the pendulum between the power parties, but a loss of momentum in the pendulum.
Disillusionment has grown against both socialists and conservatives because of the profound lack of inspiration in the former and the patent lack of competence in the latter.
Adding to Papandreou’s liabilities now is his transparent lack of talent with which to people a cabinet.
The next government ought to be made of reformers par excellence.
It cannot be a business-as-usual government, and this factor will step up people’s expectations.
Papandreou has doubled up his chief Euro-parliamentarian as his spokesman, a suggestion of penury. His shadow finance minister is a lady of dubious dependability.
Will Pasok overcome these difficulties to win in October? If Europarliament results are to be believed, some of New Democracy’s losses will come to Pasok, while others will wander to the right-wing Laos and the Ecogreens. But the majority of voters are in hiatus: A mere 52 percent of the electorate showed up on June 7.
Will this performance be repeated on October 4?
The level of abstention will probably be higher than usual. The power parties will have to work hard to say something new or appealing.
Voters will have to choose between Karamanlis’ combination of dour realism and ponderous responsibility, and Papandreou’s whiskey sour cocktail of populism, green innovation and broken-record criticism of Karamanlis.
Neither performance is likely to bring voters to the combined near-80 percent of the vote necessary to keep the two-party system going.
Right now it looks as though we are likely to see a Pasok coalition in October or a re-match in November, when the Pavlopoulos election law will give 50 seats to the front-runner rather than the current bonus of 40.
- Register Now
- Turkey condemns NSW's genocide recognition
- Mykonos: Something to 'Crowe' about
- Greek community pays tribute to Hazel Hawke
- Recognising genocide
- Fitch upgrades Greece's credit rating
- Angelopoulos' Greek drama
- Greek men affected by crisis
- New rules for reverse mortgages
- Kastellorizian Association names their best
- Philippoussis vs furry animals
- 8 May 2013 | 13 Votes
- 3 May 2013 | 9 Votes
- 15 May 2013 | 9 Votes
- 8 May 2013 | 9 Votes
- 13 May 2013 | 8 Votes
- 22 May 2013 | 7 Votes
More from this Section
- Recognising genocide
- When the pillars are shaken
- National language survival
- A personal observation
- Economic assassins
- Cypriot tax haven spoils long gone
- The bookstore of the hearth
- How Greece's once-mighty Pasok party fell from grace
- Germany: The ruler of 'New Europe' - would it qualify?
The actor who immortalised Zorba the Greek - Anthony Quinn - has put his Greek and Roman antiques up for sale
Local and international artists that express Greek themes and ideas through their art will be showcased at the Colours of Greece on Parade, held by Festival Hellenika.
It's time for Victorians of Germanic ancestry to come in from the cold, says Michael Pearce SC
Coach Graham Arnold still has high hopes for a win next week
Melbourne man John Karatzaferis is suing Qatar Airways for allegedly aggravating a previous injury after he was hit by the drinks cart during a flight
Karithopita was the first cake I made from Mum's new cookbook by Sofia Skoura. It was my mum's new Tselemende and we were all so excited, says chef Kathy Tsaples
The competition includes works written in the Greek or English language in the following categories: Poetry, Short Story and One Act Theatrical Play.
A dancer for more than 15 years, 20-year-old Natalie Marinopoulos will shine in the world's first amateur production of the famous musical, The Phantom Of The Opera
Mitchell Duke and Trent Sainsbury of the Mariners are among 12 Australian-based players selected for a Socceroos training camp
Moving through protests, strikes and tons of graffiti, she finds the embattled capital still shows glimmers of hope.
Director Oliver Stone wished SYRIZA leader Alexis Tsipras 'good luck' in leading Greece.
European and Siglo owner, Con Christopoulos will be opening a new cafe on Hardware Lane in Melbourne
The ratings agency believes the country has stabilised and moved its rating up to B-
Tv personality, Helen Kapalos was the guest of honour at Alphington Grammar's Mother's Day High Tea
Jim Raptis says he owes the Australian Tax Office no money and will not be paying a $21 million tax bill.
Head coach John Aloisi is on a scouting hunt in Europe
Star players like Del Piero, Ono and Rojas all made the fan pick, but many could be poached to play for the Socceroos in the East Asian Cup finals
Shadow treasurer Joe Hockey has mounted a passionate defence of Tony Abbott's paid parental leave scheme and branded dissident Liberal backbencher Alex Hawke