Melbourne: Few clouds, 11 °C

Sydney: Clear sky, 14 °C

Athens: Scattered clouds, 26 °C

Atkinson is NOT a phil-hellene!

Node Tools
(2)

Rate This

3.46154
39 votes
Your rating: None
3 Nov 2009

 

I read with quite some shock at the title ‘trantellena’ (30 times Greek) bestowed upon the South Australian Justice Minister Michael Atkinson on the Neos Kosmos website.

The title was part of an award called the Golden Trantellena Award that was handed over to the Minister by the Federation of Pontian Associations of Australia at a function in Adelaide.

Not only do I find this title un-befitting to this man, but I find it quite offensive! For the following reasons.

Mr. Atkinson is being labelled a ‘trantellena’ for his role in having the so called ‘Pontian’ genocide recognised in the South Australian Lower House.

The question is; why isn’t Mr. Atkinson trying to have the genocide of ALL Greeks recognised?

In other words, why isn’t he pushing for the recognition of a Greek Genocide?

If Atkinson was 30 times Greek, he should be doing more than just supporting Pontians. And that’s coming from a Pontian.

Yes, I’m Pontian. But first and foremost, I am Greek!

You see, the genocide wasn’t only inflicted on Pontic Greeks. It was inflicted on ALL Greeks of the former Ottoman Empire during the years 1914-1923.

During this period, upwards of 1 million Greeks perished in a state sponsored plan to eradicate all Greeks from the Empire.

Pontic Greeks state that 353,000 Greeks perished in the Pontus region alone.

Pontic Greek scholar Haris Tsirkinidis in his latest book ‘A historical outline of the Genocide of the Greeks of Anatolia’ (Συνοποτική ιστορία της Γενοκτονίας των Ελλήνων της Ανατολής, 2009) states that 1.5 million Greeks perished during the genocide period.

The majority of these Greeks he states were living outside the region of Pontus. Tsirkinidis refuses to use the term ‘Pontian’ genocide. As does Vlassis Agtzidis, another prominent historian of Pontic descent.

Pontian organisations both here and overseas have for decades been using the term ‘Pontian’ genocide.

Well it has to stop. The term does not describe history as it occurred. In fact in many regards it is a distortion of history.

The genocide was a Greek Genocide. Greeks perished. The Pontians too were Greek. But they cannot have the genocide tag merely for themselves.

Quite simply it is selfish and does not pay due respect to the other Greeks who were killed during the same period.

Genocide is the intention to destroy an ethnic, national or religious group. The ethnic group targeted in this instance was the Greeks. This included the Greeks of Pontus.

Genocide doesn’t confine itself to just regions as the Pontians would have us believe.

It’s time we Greeks united and called the genocide a Greek Genocide. And it’s time Pontians united under the same umbrella as all other Greeks who were affected by this catastrophic event in history.

Please. The exclusivity of suffering that Pontians are employing by using the term ‘Pontian’ genocide must stop.

And if Mr. Atkinson is in fact a ‘trantellena’ and a Justice Minister, he must recognise the death of ALL Greeks, not just the Pontians. Please Mr Atkinson, read some Greek history before attempting to rewrite it.

It was a Greek Genocide. Not a ‘Pontian’ genocide!

Aris Tsilfidis, Melbourne VIC

Read more from

Comments

The motion was obviously compiled BY Pontians FOR Pontians. Notice they mentioned that other Hellenes were killed, but in clause e) they mention the term Pontian Genocide. How can it be a Pontian Genocide when Greeks outside of Pontos were killed?

Clause b) only mentions Pontian Greeks.

Why does clause a) only allow Pontian Greek Australians to mourn the victims? Again, only Pontians are taken into account.

The motion was a shocker.

What I'd like to know is... How can Neos Kosmos publish junk like this? I thought Neos Kosmos represented ALL Greeks. The fact they publish things about a Pontian Genocide only goes to show how little NEos Kosmos knows about the issue. It wasn't a Pontian Genocide. Other Greeks died too.

I am amazed at how narrow minded some people can be if this idiot actually read the motion passed by Mr Michael Atkinson he would keep his baseless opinions to himself.

And this guy considers himself a Pontain and a proud Greek it is people like this that have set our mother nation back every time we attempt to go forward. In having the pontain genocide recognized by the worlds governments we take the first step in having all the atrocities that were inflicted on not just Pontains or Greeks in general but of all the Christian minorities in Asia Minor and Anatolia under the Ottomans and the Young Turks.

The motion introduced by Attorney-General, the Hon. Michael Atkinson MP in the South Australian Parliament is outlined as follows:

That, whereas the genocide by the Ottoman state between 1915-1923 of Armenians, Hellenes, Syrian and other minorities in Asia Minor is one of the greatest crimes against humanity, the people of South Australia and this House –

(a) join the members of the Armenian-Australian, Pontian Greek-Australian and Syrian-Australian communities in honouring the memory of the innocent men, women and children who fell victim to the first modern genocide;

(b) condemns the genocide of the Armenians, Pontian Greeks, Syrian Orthodox and other Christian minorities, and all other acts of genocide as the ultimate act of racial, religious and cultural intolerance;

(c) recognises the importance of remembering and learning from such dark chapters in human history to ensure that such crimes against humanity are not allowed to be repeated;

(d) condemns and prevents all attempts to use the passage of time to deny or distort the historical truth of the genocide of the Armenians and other acts of genocide committed during this century;

(e) acknowledges the significant humanitarian contribution made by the people of South Australia to the victims and survivors of the Armenian Genocide and the Pontian Genocide; and

(f) calls on the Commonwealth Parliament officially to condemn the genocide.

Post new comment

Enter your Neos Kosmos username.
Enter the password that accompanies your username.

Copyright © 2009-2012 Ethnic Publications Pty Ltd | Website development by ANSO