Ancient Greek splendour and brutality - a template for now
In his book From Democrats to Kings: The Brutal Dawn of a New World, MICHAEL C. SCOTT examines the period between the Athenian Democracy and Alexander the Great and considers how it resembles our world. Here he writes exclusively for Neos Kosmos.
Australian Special Forces in Afghanistan, are they maintaining an ideological and cultural value-set first established by Ancient Spartans? Are we destined to live out the same conflicts that the ancients did? Some of the issues that Dr Michael C. Scott deals with in his book, From Democrats to Kings: The Brutal Dawn of a New World.
When people think of ancient Greece, they most usually think of either democratic Athens – with its shining Parthenon atop the Acropolis resplendent then as it is today – or they think of the legendary exploits of Alexander the Great.
But what few people realise is that these two extremes of the political spectrum – democracy and absolute monarchy – were separated in the ancient Greek world by a period of about 80 years: a single lifetime in which the ancient Greek world was turned completely on its head. It is a crucial period in ancient Greece's story and yet one which has attracted surprisingly little attention from both scholars and the wider public. It is, instead, often labelled simply as the sickly cousin of more glorious moments in Greece's history.
From Democrats to Kings: The Brutal Dawn of a New World seeks to reverse this trend by putting the spotlight directly on this single lifetime of dramatic change which turned the ancient Greek world on its head. The book seeks to understand how and why the Greek world changed so quickly, how the different individuals and cities of Greece coped in such a turbulent world, to follow their successes and failures and, ultimately, to think about why this period of history – this single lifetime over 2000 years ago – is still worth our consideration today.
Why should we care about ancient Greece? First, there is, of course, our inherent human fascination with our own past; you just have to look at the response to recent archaeological discoveries (the Anglo-Saxon gold hoard in Britain, or the new amphitheatre discovered near the harbour of Portus in Italy) to see this Indiana Jones part of our human psyche. But it is more than that. We also have a lot of ancient Greece embedded in our world's languages, systems of government and culture and, as a result, we need to be aware of its ancestry. But, most importantly, we also often actively choose to use ancient Greece as an exhortative example for our future.
America cherishes its unbroken links to Athenian democracy, Greece has just voted Alexander the Great as the Greatest Greek of all time on national TV, and books on Spartan military tactics are being supplied to soldiers on the front line in Afghanistan. It is difficult to know sometimes how appropriate these exhortations are.
What are we buying into when we tell soldiers to fight like Spartans for example? But the very fact that we continue to make them also makes it more important than ever that we investigate, discuss and debate at every level of our society what ancient Greece was and how it should be appropriately incorporated into our world.
From Democrats to Kings contributes to that debate by bringing the spotlight on a too-often-forgotten period of turbulent, and crucial, change in the history of ancient Greece that links two of the most often used modern-day exhortative examples (Athenian democracy and Alexander the Great). A focus on the single lifetime that links these two extremes helps to underline the changing nature of the ancient Greek world and adds texture and depth to our understanding of what ancient Greece was.
But I think it can also help in our search for a useful way of involving the ancient world in the modern. As an example of what I mean, lets look briefly at the city of Athens during this period of turbulent change.
- Show full page
- Login or register to post comments
-

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
-
The nothingness of 'I am Hellene'(3)
-
ANZAC Day in Greece(1)
-
A 'Good Move' for Melburnians(1)
-
The forgotten Greek ANZACs(1)
-
EU expresses concern about Chrysi Avgi(1)
-
New elections looming for Greece(1)
More from this Section
- Stepping out of the shadows of stigma
- The Greeks who fought for Australia
- Meet the man behind the game
- The uncrowned Greek Australian king of the West
- 100 years of Castellorizians in the west
- Awaking the giant
- Golden age of Greek cinema
- Raising awareness for thalassaemia
- The sultana man of Mildura
- Cyprus issue, bigger than expected
-
Heavy metal fan Michela Rabia gets up close and personal with heavy metal editor Olivia Reppas.
-
Trivia night for cancer is on again! Enjoy a night filled with fun prizes, delicious mezes and a tad of healthy rivalry as all vie for the title of trivia master.
-
Nick Kaloterakis talks to Neos Kosmos about working with director James Cameron’s team to present a historically accurate reconstruction of the Titanic.
-
Language school groups have joined forces in a bid to pressure the ACT Government to increase funding for ethnic language schools in the ACT.
-
With only a little over half of Greek beaches manned by lifesavers, one Gold Coaster is doing his best to educate Greeks on swimming between the flags.
-
Compromise reached over new caretaker premier following tense meeting of party leaders.
-
Panayiotis Pikrammenos vows to safeguard country's 'standing, transition'.
-
The government and Jewish community condemned the leader of the neo-Nazi Golden Dawn for saying there were no gas chambers in Nazi concentration camps.
-
Athina and her Daughters: a memoir of two worlds (in English and in Greek), by author Helen Nickas will be launched next week in Melbourne.
-
The 1st edition of the Greek Law Digest, The Ultimate Legal Guide to Investing in Greece has been launched.
-
Melbourne's New Year's Eve dwellers will be treated to a glimmering night out as the city's festivities will be inspired by the gold rush era.
-
PASOK is due to hold elections for a new leader on March 18 and officials close to current party chief George Papandreou insist that he has no intention in taking part.
-
JENNY MIKAKOS believes there should be an even distribution of resources between Asian and European languages.
-
Soccer matches prove good for morale for refugees
-
The Federation of Greek Communities of Australia has signed an interim agreement with the 'Old Calendar' Orthodox in an attempt to legitimise its members religious status.
-
Victoria Kyriakopoulos talks to Arthur Sinodinos, the man many attribute with John Howard's political success
-
A year since the introduction of a blanket ban on smoking in public places, businesses and smokers alike continue to flagrantly flout the law.
-
Prime Minister George Papandreou is to receive a World No Tobacco Day Award
-
GOCMV'S President Bill Papastergiadis foresees more community donations fuelling the rise of Melbourne's Hellenic Cultural Centre.
-
A handwritten letter from Paul McCartney offering a Beatles audition to a mystery drummer has sold for almost GBP35,000 ($55,174), Christie's auction house has said.
-
The ongoing investigation into the Siemens bribery scandal in Greece has seen two former Siemens executives detained in jail and an international warrant arrest for the former CEO.
-
The RBA did not cut official interest rates on Tuesday leading some economists to predict that the big banks will raise their mortgage rates to cover increased funding costs in a move that would raise the ire of politicians and borrowers.
-
UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon stressed that considerable progress has been achieved in the Cyprus UN peace talks in his report to the Security Council.
-
Farmers are threatening to block traffic on major roads in Greece today (Monday) to demand full payment of subsidies they are entitled to and better prices for their produce.
-
Flavours of Greece kicks off all over Melbourne this week
-
If you are struggling to maintain your New Years resolutions, here’s some tips to help you succeed when you have lapsed.
-
Prime Minister George Papandreou begins meetings aimed at finalising plans for sell-offs
-
Aegean Airlines took the market by surprise last week when it announced it is in talks with rival Olympic Air on a possible deal “for possible cooperation,” adding that there is nothing specific yet to announce.


















