Melbourne: Broken clouds, 15 °C

Sydney: Broken clouds, 16 °C

Athens: Few clouds, 24 °C

Ancient Greek splendour and brutality - a template for now

In his book From Democrats to Kings: The Brutal Dawn of a New World, MICHAEL C. SCOTT examines the period between the Athenian Democracy and Alexander the Great and considers how it resembles our world. Here he writes exclusively for Neos Kosmos.

Node Tools
(0)

Rate This

0
No votes yet
Your rating: None
Australian Special Forces in Afghanistan, trained as Spartans.

Australian Special Forces in Afghanistan, are they maintaining an ideological and cultural value-set first established by Ancient Spartans? Are we destined to live out the same conflicts that the ancients did? Some of the issues that Dr Michael C. Scott deals with in his book, From Democrats to Kings: The Brutal Dawn of a New World.

America cherishes its unbroken links to Athenian democracy, Greece has just voted Alexander the Great as the Greatest Greek of all time on national TV and books on Spartan military tactics are being supplied to soldiers on the front line in Afghanistan.
9 Nov 2009

When people think of ancient Greece, they most usually think of either democratic Athens – with its shining Parthenon atop the Acropolis resplendent then as it is today – or they think of the legendary exploits of Alexander the Great.

But what few people realise is that these two extremes of the political spectrum – democracy and absolute monarchy – were separated in the ancient Greek world by a period of about 80 years: a single lifetime in which the ancient Greek world was turned completely on its head. It is a crucial period in ancient Greece's story and yet one which has attracted surprisingly little attention from both scholars and the wider public. It is, instead, often labelled simply as the sickly cousin of more glorious moments in Greece's history.

From Democrats to Kings: The Brutal Dawn of a New World seeks to reverse this trend by putting the spotlight directly on this single lifetime of dramatic change which turned the ancient Greek world on its head. The book seeks to understand how and why the Greek world changed so quickly, how the different individuals and cities of Greece coped in such a turbulent world, to follow their successes and failures and, ultimately, to think about why this period of history – this single lifetime over 2000 years ago – is still worth our consideration today.

Why should we care about ancient Greece? First, there is, of course, our inherent human fascination with our own past; you just have to look at the response to recent archaeological discoveries (the Anglo-Saxon gold hoard in Britain, or the new amphitheatre discovered near the harbour of Portus in Italy) to see this Indiana Jones part of our human psyche. But it is more than that. We also have a lot of ancient Greece embedded in our world's languages, systems of government and culture and, as a result, we need to be aware of its ancestry. But, most importantly, we also often actively choose to use ancient Greece as an exhortative example for our future.

America cherishes its unbroken links to Athenian democracy, Greece has just voted Alexander the Great as the Greatest Greek of all time on national TV, and books on Spartan military tactics are being supplied to soldiers on the front line in Afghanistan. It is difficult to know sometimes how appropriate these exhortations are.

What are we buying into when we tell soldiers to fight like Spartans for example? But the very fact that we continue to make them also makes it more important than ever that we investigate, discuss and debate at every level of our society what ancient Greece was and how it should be appropriately incorporated into our world.

From Democrats to Kings contributes to that debate by bringing the spotlight on a too-often-forgotten period of turbulent, and crucial, change in the history of ancient Greece that links two of the most often used modern-day exhortative examples (Athenian democracy and Alexander the Great). A focus on the single lifetime that links these two extremes helps to underline the changing nature of the ancient Greek world and adds texture and depth to our understanding of what ancient Greece was.

But I think it can also help in our search for a useful way of involving the ancient world in the modern. As an example of what I mean, lets look briefly at the city of Athens during this period of turbulent change.

Read more from

Copyright © 2009-2010 Ethnic Publications Pty Ltd | Website development by ANSO