The Turkish lobby in Germany
Unspoken tensions erupt in Berlin over relations between “guest workers” from Turkey and Greece as they face new cultural hurdles
In the 1950s and 1960s, the prospering economy of West Germany was searching for more workers and got them from other countries, especially Italy, Greece, Yugoslavia and Turkey. This economic-based explanation was dominant for decades. Until the last years scientific investigations uncovered that political reasons had a much greater importance. The West German Ministry of the Interior was skeptical about hiring non-European workers and therefore warned against introducing Turkish workers to Germany.
But in 1960, West Germany signed a "guest worker" agreement with Greece. Turkish officials expressed the view that treating Turkey differently to Greece would be an insult for the NATO Partner. They wanted equal treatment. So the State Department of West Germany, with the German administration, outvoted the Ministry of Interior and Germany signed a guest worker treaty with Turkey in 1961.
The Turks, who were at the beginning only a small number of the whole of the so-called Gastarbeiter (guest workers) grew to become the dominating group in the beginning of the 1970s. The end of authoritarian regimes in Portugal, Spain and Greece in the 1970s, together with the decreasing need of handwork-workforce in German factories led to the return of many guest workers to their home countries - except the Turks, because Turkey was economically and politically unstable throughout the 1970s and 1980s.
The deep cultural rift between Germans and Turks made sentiments of hostility frequent in this relationship. Similar sentiments may have occurred also with Italians and Greeks in the 1960s and 1970s, but never to the same extent as with the Turks, because both groups of South Europeans are Christians, and the Greeks particularly benefited from the esteem held for their ancient ancestors. Nowadays, Greek and Italian restaurants are part of everyday life of the Germans; this may also be true for the doner kebab of Turkish take-outs, because it became the favourite snack of the Germans and it is meanwhile probably easier to get a doner kebab in a German city than a Bratwurst sausage.
But gastronomic preferences don't necessarily match cultural approach. For many Germans, Turks still represent an alien element in Germany. They often feel this way because Turks, unlike the Italians for example, hardly mix with Germans in relationships. They prefer to marry in their own ethnic group, read their own newspapers, watch Turkish television and the gigantic mosques which are built in German cities since a few years produce rejection, and not only among conservative Germans. Most Germans may not even know that there are many Greek language high schools in Germany because the Greeks are a silent minority. In contrast, Turkish Prime Minister Erdogan demanded Turkish schools in Germany, and raised a wave of popular outrage.
But the Turks have meanwhile outnumbered all other nations of former guest workers, and German politicians made more and more allowances for this fact in the last decades. Chancellor Kohl (1982-1998) of the conservative party CDU promised to reduce the number of strangers entering upon office (and all knew that he meant the Turks, not all strangers), but after a few results with financial inducements, the Turkish immigration began once more in the mid-1980s. Nowadays, in Germany, a land of 82 million, there are about 3 million people with Turkish roots; about half of them, 1.6 million, still holding Turkish citizenship. The Italians, the second largest group of strangers in Germany, account for about 500,000 people. There are less than 300,000 Greek nationals in Germany, making them the fourth strongest group of immigrants after Turks, Italians and Poles. Germany ranges fourth in worldwide diaspora population of Greeks after the US, Great Britain and Australia.
German-Greek relations were good for many decades. Hundreds of thousands of Greeks worked hard in Germany and earned good money; millions of Germans travelled to Greece in the summer and enjoyed Greek hospitality. Only the Euro crises caused some resentment on both sides. But this cannot be compared to the extensive antipathy for Turks by Germans - and the way, on the contrary, German politicians are flattering the strongest group of strangers because they want their votes.
Though a majority of Germans don't want Turkey to become a member of the European Union, preparations for this membership are in hand. Though almost every building of a new mosque in a German city produces fears and rejection from Germans, political leaders play down such Islamization-Turkification as positive sign of a multicultural society and diversity. Open speech about negative sides of immigration of Turks is seldom; but in 2010, a member of the famous Bundesbank, the central bank of Germany, Thilo Sarrazin, published a best seller with his book Deutschland schafft sich ab (Germany abolishes itself). The social democrat Sarrazin could not be defamed as a right-wing extremist, and his pointing to Muslims and Turks in Germany as increasing groups unwilling to integrate into German society produced enormous echoes by way of discussions on television, radio broadcasting, newspapers, magazines and internet forums.
In 1974, when Turkey invaded Cyprus, some Turks and Greeks brawled in German factories instead of working. Nowadays, relations are peaceful - on the surface. The Turkish lobby, the Turkish pressure groups grew increasingly powerful in the last years. Functionaries of these pressure groups deny the genocide of the Armenians 1915 without being outlawed for it.
- Register Now
- Golden Dawn's Australian aspirations uncovered
- More Greeks calling Australia home
- Paedophilia charge for Greek Australian
- Greek Adelaide church in hot water again
- Sixth place for Alcohol is Free
- AFP show support for Cyprus
- Do it like the Greeks says German consul
- Fans make the Wanderers a good investment
- Man sues Qatar over drinks car accident
- Marxist reporter won praise for his work
- 8 May 2013 | 12 Votes
- 15 May 2013 | 9 Votes
- 8 May 2013 | 8 Votes
- 3 May 2013 | 8 Votes
- 13 May 2013 | 7 Votes
- 30 Apr 2013 | 6 Votes
More from this Section
- When the pillars are shaken
- National language survival
- A personal observation
- Economic assassins
- Cypriot tax haven spoils long gone
- The bookstore of the hearth
- How Greece's once-mighty Pasok party fell from grace
- Germany: The ruler of 'New Europe' - would it qualify?
- Revolution unblinkered
Round seven of NSW League Two preview
Public Order Minister Nikos Dendias is considering measures that could lead to far-right Golden Dawn being outlawed
The party had consistently spent 30 per cent more than it earned over its time in power
Unemployment in Greece more than twice the average rate in the euro zone
Bank of Sydney customers and guests gathered last week to launch their new Marrickville branch.
A rush of withdrawals would put additional strain on the banks that Cyprus can hardly afford at the moment
Cafe owners embrace goodwill scheme for the less fortunate
All Windows Open was voted for its accurate portrayal of child migrants
The Eurovision Song Competition still remains the most watched non-sporting event of the year. Greece's entry is unique, but will it win?
Jim Raptis says he owes the Australian Tax Office no money and will not be paying a $21 million tax bill.
NSW is Australia's first state to recognise the genocides and hopes are that other states will follow
Allowable expenses widened for small businesses in 2012-2013
A lecture on Ancient Greek jewellery 'Mycenaean to Hellenistic' will be on this Wednesday at the Greek Community Centre in South Brisbane
Moyne mayor Jim Doukas says the State government has unfairly dumped permit approval on Councils
Historian Jim Claven tours the modern-day city and reflects on the Byzantine and Orthodox legacy.
Internet based sister classes connect Greek classrooms to Australian ones in a way to collaboratively learn the language
The Greek sponsored club tried for a second time to buy the club, putting $3.5 million on the table
Is Greek Easter the only time young Greek Australians make it to church? Neos Kosmos investigates what draws young parishioners.