Reinventing heritage buildings isn’t new at all – the ancients did it too
Exploring principles such as sustainable urban planning, adaptive reuse and recycling heritage, and their long history in the ancient world
In any debate on new construction in our urban centres you are likely to hear phrases like sustainable urban planning, adaptive reuse and recycling heritage – so much so that anyone would be forgiven for thinking that these were modern concerns.
However, these principles have a long history in the ancient world. Anywhere permanent materials such as marble and granite were used to build monuments and infrastructure, recycling and reuse followed.
The ancient Roman world is littered with examples of architectural recycling. Under the banner spolia studies, archaeologists and art historians have increasingly focused attention on the hows and whys of reuse in antiquity.
Ancient architectural recycling falls into two broad categories: adaptive reuse of immovable structures, when a building or monument is renovated and its primary function changes; and reuse of architectural elements, where both functional and decorative material is removed from one building to be incorporated in another (spolia).
While this is often associated with changes in ideologies, there is also evidence of opportunistic recycling following disasters. These events created a surplus of materials that could be salvaged for new constructions.
Same aesthetic, new function
In the hearts of Rome and Istanbul, the capitals of the ancient Roman and Byzantine empires, stand the Pantheon and Hagia Sophia. These iconic and celebrated public buildings were adapted for different religious purposes throughout history. Both maintained their heritage aesthetic, while renovating their function.
The Pantheon was adapted from a pagan temple to a consecrated church in 609CE. The exterior Pantheon was largely unchanged, while the interior was stripped of its pagan elements.
Hagia Sophia was adapted from a Christian basilica to an Islamic mosque following the fall of Constantinople to the Ottomans. The exterior required only the addition of minarets. The interior was whitewashed to cover the rich mosaics of its previous life.
Civic buildings, too, were prime candidates for adaptive reuse, thanks to the rich materials and design of their original constructions.
At the newly listed UNESCO World Heritage site of Ephesus, the tourists’ visit culminates at the impressive multistorey Library of Celsus. Originally built in the second century, an earthquake and fire destroyed the library and its holdings in 262CE.
The impressive facade of the library was salvaged and adapted 100 years later into a nymphaeum, a public water fountain. The adaptive process incorporated other recycled materials from nearby public monuments, mostly marble blocks and free-standing sculpture, fitting the change in function. This reuse gave the non-functional, but already historic, structure a new life.
The restored Library of Celsus, Ephesus, with excavated ancient water pipes in the foreground. Photo: touringephesus.com/
Recycling as propaganda
The Arch of Constantine is possibly the most referenced structure in spolia studies. Dedicated in 315, the arch celebrates Constantine’s victory over his rival Emperor Maxentius at the Battle of Milvian Bridge.
First noticed by Raphael, the arch was built from a mixture of new and recycled decorative building material. Scenes of animal hunts, religious sacrifice and historic battles were taken from monuments built in the second century CE, including those of the emperors Hadrian, Trajan and Marcus Aurelius. These scenes represented the “golden years” of Rome’s past.
Constantine didn’t just simply recycle these pieces; he reworked the stone faces of Rome’s greatest emperors into his own image. With this act, the emperor takes on all the great qualities of his predecessors and sets himself up as the rightful leader of Rome. This recycling takes us into a world of political propaganda, something the Romans were renowned for.
This bold inclusion of old material in a new monument for Rome led to a whole new recycling trend in architecture. Decorative elements such as columns, capitals and architraves were given new life in buildings of the fourth century CE.
The trend became so popular that new laws were created to protect public buildings from being stripped of their decoration. Only if a building could not be restored was it permitted to recycle that building’s materials.
The Arch of Constantine, where recycling even serves the purpose of propaganda. Photo: open.conted.ox.ac.uk
Natural disasters and invading armies often left ancient monuments in ruin. These created a stock of marble, granite and sandstone that could be reused in new constructions.
In Nea Paphos, Cyprus, a devastating earthquake destroyed the 8,500-seat theatre in 365CE. Instead of being rebuilt, the theatre became a useful source of marble and stone. Many of the columns and decorative architecture were carried off to be reused in the new Chrysopolitissa basilica, 300 metres down the road.
In Athens, the invading Heruli destroyed several public buildings in 267-8 CE. However, this left behind a good supply of reusable materials. The Athenians recycled many elements, from column drums to relief sculpture, in a large fortification wall circling the heart of the city. Today, the wall appears as a hodgepodge of recycled elements from Athens’ classical past.
In 2004, the Australian Department of the Environment and Energy released a document supporting adaptive reuse. This booklet said:
Historic buildings give us a glimpse of our past and lend character to our communities as well as serving practical purposes now.
In 2011, the renamed department released a guide to help realise new recycling opportunities related to construction and demolition. These principles are part of our general thinking about urban planning. However, it is clear that this is not a new approach to sustainable urban development, but rather continues an ancient tradition of recycling.
* This article first appeared on The Conversation, www.theconversation.com
- Register Now
- Tsim Booky speaks to Neos Kosmos
- Is your Greek property on forestland?
- Milo Yiannopoulos' forthcoming memoir will not be published in Australia
- Women of Greece taking to the rugby field
- Greek Tourism Professor wins another international award
- The Vow of the Nation
- The 'Bell Bearers' of Eastern Macedonia come to Melbourne
- Corruption still riding high in crestfallen Greece
- Roar signs former Greek international defender
- Enosis Day vote threatens Cyprus talks
- Tsim Booky speaks to Neos Kosmos
- In memory of 16-month-old Nikki Adipas
- 'The New York Times' picks Greece, Australia and Cyprus among best places to visit in 2017
- Greeks among the hardest-working population in the world
- James Penlidis has the answer: Go naked!
- 138 violations of Greek airspace by Turkish aircraft
- Bougias of Bourke Street
- Bulleen project to set Melbourne up as Hellenic global diaspora headquarters
- WWII Bomb forces people to evacuate Thessaloniki
- When Melbourne went blue and white
If the changes get the go-ahead, philologists fear it will be another blow to Classical scholarship, occurring across the globe.
My big fat Greek week.
Fringe World Perth 2017 welcomes the symbiotic ethos of art, technology and myth as showcased by Australia's leading Greek creatives.
Denmark's message to Greece: 'Show us how to be more like you!'
Don't be surprised if your patriko or olive grove in your hometown village has been identified as forestry land under new regulations
The Greek Community of Melbourne expects a large turnout on Sunday at the special and general meetings.
Dean Kalimniou responds to a controversial photograph showing a group of Greek soldiers of Albanian ethnicity linking their outstretched hands to form the double-headed eagle.
Restaurateurs Tony and Peter Giannakis are moving on − having put Port Melbourne on the fine-dining map.
Although not a household name among Australian sports fans, he remains one of the giants of the sport due to his extraordinary goal scoring feats in the 1950s and '60s.
Scoot fares are now on sale from Australia to Athens starting from July 4.
A major celebratory dinner was held in Ballarat with over 100 attendees.
Join them for a makeup photographic experience that will transform you.
Bouzanis's absence couldn't have come at a worse time for City ahead of this week's home match against Brisbane Roar.
South Melbourne has announced several measures which it believes are a positive outcome of its One Club policy.
Archaeologists dubbed it '7,000-year-old enigma' as they don't know its provenance and can't explain its irregular size and matter.
Sydney and Melbourne in the top 10 most expensive cities in the world.
The outright majority points to the German government as cause for delay, while support for Syriza remains strong
The former Swansea City striker is looking to get his career back on track in Cyprus.