Modern pic disasters? I don’t think so!
Cambridge Fellow Michael C Scott this week tackles Hollywood’s obsession with the ancient epics
We are in an era of sandals and swords epic movies. Gladiator, 300, Alexander, Troy, not to mention a spate of recent TV series (the HBO/BBC2 series Rome) and fictional spin offs (Percy Jackson and the Lightening Thief in cinemas now). More are in the pipeline (a rumored version of Xenophon’s Anabasis amongst others). The movie world, it seems, is in love with ancient Greece and Rome.
Many commentators though complain at the lack of historical accuracy in these films, moan about casting choices and ridicule the changing or simplifying of plot lines. These epics movies are epic disasters they claim.
But I don’t think so. Sure, all the above criticisms may be right. But I don’t think that qualifies them as epic disasters. In fact, they remind us about an important aspect of ancient myths and legends: that they changed.
Epics like the Iliad for example weren’t written down in the ancient world for an awfully long time; they existed initially as oral poetry and their story-line changed over the generations.
There was no one true script; it was constantly in flux. Equally, when the story of the Iliad was more or less ‘fixed’, then another genre of art – Greek tragedy – took up the reins to play with our reaction to the great epics by focusing on the ‘before and after’ e.g. what do we think of Agamemnon in the Iliad when we see that he will be killed by his wife on his return home, or the hero Odysseus when we see him having to trick a fellow Greek into coming to Troy after Odysseus had abandoned the same man on a deserted island some years before?
Alexander the Great offers a different example of how the ancient world is presented to us today. There are several ancient sources that survive for us about Alexander, each of which offers a slightly different take on Alexander’s character and his actions.
The point here is that there is not one obviously correct story, but competing interpretations and we each have to decide how to weigh the evidence – how we see Alexander.
If these Hollywood film adaptations can thus spawn debate and discussion about these key stories, places and peoples of our past, then, whatever their cinematic quality, they have done us a great service by continuing the great traditions of the ancient world.
A book has just been published which focuses on responses to the characterization of Alexander the Great in Oliver Stone’s movie Alexander. The movie, whether you liked it or not, seems to have got people thinking and that can’t be a bad thing.
Michael C Scott is the author of ‘From Democrats to Kings - The Brutal Dawn of a New World from the Downfall of Athens to the Rise of Alexander the Great’ www.michaelcscott.com
- Register Now
- Community condemns ERT closure
- Court orders Greek broadcaster ERT back on air
- Abusive crackdown on migrants
- Modern Greek tragedy
- ERT's demise impacts SBS
- Xenophon warns of data sweep danger
- Outstanding Greek Australians honoured
- ERT suspension 'sinful', says Megrelis
- The thief strikes back
- Taxi laws passed as dissenters regroup
- 10 Jun 2013 | 16 Votes
- 22 May 2013 | 16 Votes
- 28 May 2013 | 14 Votes
- 30 May 2013 | 12 Votes
- 11 Jun 2013 | 7 Votes
- 27 May 2013 | 7 Votes
More from this Section
- How to survive a siege
- A new visual Homer?
- An Ancient Greek walks into a bar...
- The Spectacle of drama
- Carrot pill anyone?
- More than just a game-the ancient Greek Olympics
- A Greek community on the boundary
- How did Praxiteles see me naked?
- Inventories of the ancient world
- Inventories of the ancient world
The Socceroos were in form and unstopable during their World Cup qualifying match against Jordan
Akis Tsochatzopoulos, the former defense minister being tried for money laundering, allegedly received kickbacks for defense contracts as far back as 1997
The hypocrisy is stark and blatant. Syria is a terrorist state whose leader must be removed while on the other hand, Turkey is permitted to invade sovereign nations
Troika to return to Athens as IMF approves new loan, assesses program errors
Former Ajax and Roda JC central defender Rob Wielaert will join Melbourne Heart for the 2013-14 season
A delicious zucchini flower fritter from the island of Ikaria.
Bill and Jim Karras pretended they were in a gay relationship to receive the first homeowners grant
Over two nights, the youngsters in Belmore United and Earlwood Wanderers sparred with Sydney FC players
Shakespeare's play Othello is set to take a Hellenic twist with a Greek Australian actor in the show as well as a stage set both in Venice and Cyprus.
State League leaders West Adelaide Hellas still remain undefeated
Adviser to PM Jean Chretien in the 1990s David Zussman on the North American country's economic turnaround.
Neofascist Golden Dawn is third with 13 percent, according to Pulse survey
Whilst acknowledging the merits and history Australia's foundations Kostas Karamarkos makes the argument for an Australian republic.
The initiative of the Greek Government to shut down ERT in order to restructure the national television and radio broadcaster is already threatening the stability of the govt
The announcement from Ford Australia to cease its vehicle and engine manufacturing operations in Australia, was extremely disappointing, Maria Vamvakinou,
Dora Kitinas-Gogos finds out the food secrets - and lifestyle choices - of a long life on the island of Ikaria
There is a lack of AFL short term on-field options for teams stagnant at the bottom of the mid-season ladder
Aussies continue to be careful with their credit cards and personal debt