Modern pic disasters? I don’t think so!
Cambridge Fellow Michael C Scott this week tackles Hollywood’s obsession with the ancient epics
We are in an era of sandals and swords epic movies. Gladiator, 300, Alexander, Troy, not to mention a spate of recent TV series (the HBO/BBC2 series Rome) and fictional spin offs (Percy Jackson and the Lightening Thief in cinemas now). More are in the pipeline (a rumored version of Xenophon’s Anabasis amongst others). The movie world, it seems, is in love with ancient Greece and Rome.
Many commentators though complain at the lack of historical accuracy in these films, moan about casting choices and ridicule the changing or simplifying of plot lines. These epics movies are epic disasters they claim.
But I don’t think so. Sure, all the above criticisms may be right. But I don’t think that qualifies them as epic disasters. In fact, they remind us about an important aspect of ancient myths and legends: that they changed.
Epics like the Iliad for example weren’t written down in the ancient world for an awfully long time; they existed initially as oral poetry and their story-line changed over the generations.
There was no one true script; it was constantly in flux. Equally, when the story of the Iliad was more or less ‘fixed’, then another genre of art – Greek tragedy – took up the reins to play with our reaction to the great epics by focusing on the ‘before and after’ e.g. what do we think of Agamemnon in the Iliad when we see that he will be killed by his wife on his return home, or the hero Odysseus when we see him having to trick a fellow Greek into coming to Troy after Odysseus had abandoned the same man on a deserted island some years before?
Alexander the Great offers a different example of how the ancient world is presented to us today. There are several ancient sources that survive for us about Alexander, each of which offers a slightly different take on Alexander’s character and his actions.
The point here is that there is not one obviously correct story, but competing interpretations and we each have to decide how to weigh the evidence – how we see Alexander.
If these Hollywood film adaptations can thus spawn debate and discussion about these key stories, places and peoples of our past, then, whatever their cinematic quality, they have done us a great service by continuing the great traditions of the ancient world.
A book has just been published which focuses on responses to the characterization of Alexander the Great in Oliver Stone’s movie Alexander. The movie, whether you liked it or not, seems to have got people thinking and that can’t be a bad thing.
Michael C Scott is the author of ‘From Democrats to Kings - The Brutal Dawn of a New World from the Downfall of Athens to the Rise of Alexander the Great’ www.michaelcscott.com
- Register Now
- Bishop soothes Turkish concerns
- Visual Chemistry
- Greece's new cabinet
- Greek singer Demis Roussos, dies age 68
- Tennis touchdown
- Greek Australians die in separate road tragedies
- Greek Australian scientist may hold obesity key
- Courses for Greek grandparents experiencing family conflict
- Greek tourism rise outshines global gains
- 'Five bodies' at Alexander-era tomb
- Rest in peace Kostas
- More layoffs than new jobs last month
- PPC considers electricity rate cuts
- Mirabella calls for more women in parliament
- Greek archives now listed online
- No extension will entail a ‘dirty’ exit from the bailout
- Greek Fava with Grilled Squid
- Odum completes PAOK's amazing comeback against AEK
- Samaras casts conservatives as guarantors of country’s European course
- Grexit the only way out of ‘valley of tears,’ says Hans-Werner Sinn
More than 3 million tourists travel to Greece from these three markets every year.
A Greek American businessman has taken up an anti-smoking campaign to save the children of Greece.
But the Greens stayed close to their host for two thirds of the game.
A documentary on the Xylouris family to hit Australia.
Wondering what to do tonight?
Speak Greek in March gathers momentum.
The Greek chairman of 20th Century Fox is considered one of the most insightful men in the industry.
As an added treat, former Magic Dirt frontwoman Adalita will join J for shows in Melbourne, Brisbane, the Gold Coast and Sydney.
Sotiris Danos - the 'golden hands' trainer behind Bernard Tomic's recovery - talks to Neos Kosmos.
Yarra City mayor outraged over 'malicious and cowardly' act in Melbourne park.
With March being celebrated as the "speak Greek" month of our community.
Was I Greek? Was I Australian? Was I an Australian Greek, or a Greek Australian?
Greece election: SYRIZA on verge of decisive victory.
Opposition SYRIZA is certain that it will be treated differently by the country’s partners and creditors.
Australian Open: Thanasi Kokkinakis stronger than ever for his second wildcard appearance.
He is expected to assume power tomorrow and could change Europe forever.
Travel receipts amounted to 13.5 billion euros.
Blogger Penny Zalalas shares her culinary secrets with Neos Kosmos, giving new mummies tasty advice their kids will love.