As News Corp became the latest media company to announce major cuts this year, one part of Australia’s news landscape continues to prove surprisingly resilient.
The country’s multicultural newspapers are by no means immune to shocks in the industry but loyal readerships and niche advertising have kept them afloat.
Multicultural newspapers in Australia date back more than 150 years and boomed in the post-WWII years as the country welcomed waves of migrants.
While many have come and gone, dozens are still operating, including the 125-year-old Australian Jewish News (AJN).
“[We service] a really strong community that is very connected,” David Redman, CEO of AJN publishers Polaris Media, told SBS News.
“It’s an advertising-driven model and we have a subscription base. That combination does help, but really, the paper’s survival is a testament to the loyalty of the community more than anything else.
“The readership is very committed to having a newspaper that is able to explore the world through their eyes and be able to give them an insight into what’s happening from their perspective.
“It always comes back to stories … What holds any community together is the stories they share, the things that they talk about.”
Publishing stories such as “My Ramadan in lockdown” and “Hospitality unconstrained through virtual iftars”, the Australasian Muslim Times (AMUST) has also weathered the recent storm of media disruption.
Editor-in-chief Zia Ahmad told SBS News the newspaper has “really flourished” since it relaunched in 2014 and that interest had increased during the pandemic.
“It has been well-received by the community,” Mr Ahmad told SBS News.
“We are not just regurgitating the TV and other newspapers. For example, there’s a murder. You’ll find that on every channel, everywhere. That same story.”
READ MORE: 60 years of Neos Kosmos
Mr Ahmad said AMUST also differentiates itself from mainstream media in other ways.
“The mainstream newspapers are talking about wars and rapes and muggings and negative news, with the understanding that negative news sells,” he said.
“We market our newspaper as a positive story newspaper … [With stories on] interfaith dialogue, people being brought together – you don’t see that in most newspapers.”
Mr Ahmad also credited the newspaper’s ongoing success with its embrace of digital platforms.
“You can’t just rely on print,” he said.
Steady advertising dollars
A key reason behind the resilience of these newspapers has been a stable advertising base that wants to target Australia’s migrant communities.
The 28 May issue of Italian language newspaper, La Fiamma, featured ads for Italian food distribution companies, Italian social clubs and in-language political advertisements for both Labor and Coalition MPs.
Dario Nelli, the editor of Sydney’s La Fiamma and its Melbourne counterpart Il Globo, said there had been consistent support from advertisers through the years.
“They want to market to the Italian community,” Mr Nelli said.
“Small firms, even big firms, clubs, associations – they can see the role of the newspaper and they support us.
“When councils want to communicate something to the Italian community they go through us … And politicians know they can reach the whole community through us.”
During the pandemic, La Fiamma, Il Globo and other multicultural newspapers have also featured COVID-19 public service announcements, often in full-page format.
As a result, Mr Nelli said he was optimistic about the future of his newspapers.
“The day is far away when there won’t be a need for La Fiamma and Il Globo. I’m optimistic we can keep going for quite a while.”
‘So much uncertainty’
However, all the outlets SBS News spoke to were keenly aware of the challenges around the news landscape, especially during the pandemic.
The Chinese language press has been particularly hard-hit this year. The Sing Tao Daily – the country’s largest and longest-running Chinese language newspaper – closed, while other publications stopped their print editions.
Christopher Gogos, the publisher of the 63-year-old Greek newspaper, Neos Kosmos, is worried about the sustainability of the newspapers in the digital age.
“We’ve had similar problems to what all other publishers have had. We’re not immune to it. Having a more niche audience and community does help … [But] there is still so much uncertainty,” he said.
Mr Gogos said readership is booming, but this is largely thanks to the digital version of the newspaper.
“It’s encouraging that there are a lot of people reading us in the digital space, but like every other publisher in the world, it’s about monetising that … How do we get decent enough revenue to have paid journalists and to make it sustainable.”
Mr Gogos said multicultural newspapers like Neos Kosmos play a vital role in Australia.
“We don’t just exist for commercial reasons … What we provide, there’s a community need for it,” he said.
“It’s important that we have community discussions, it’s part of the public discourse, part of our debate, part of our democracy, it’s critical.”
He said Australia would be far worse off if multicultural newspapers closed.
“The problem I see, if there is no viability for multicultural media to exist, you’re going to have a vacuum and it’s going to be filled up with discussions on Facebook and other social media and the quality of our information will deteriorate,” he said.
“It will be really sad if that happens.”
It is a point echoed by Tim Soutphommasane, Australia’s former race discrimination commissioner who is now the director of culture strategy at the University of Sydney.
“[These newspapers] are often invisible to Australians who don’t read them. But the reality is in multicultural Australian society, members of our community get their news from multiple sources, not only from English language sources,” Mr Soutphommasane said.
He said for new arrivals to Australia, these mastheads can “form an important bridge between one’s home county and one’s new country”.
“Mainstream Australian English language media just does not resemble what our multicultural society looks like in any meaningful form … We will lose diversity if we see these media outlets folding,” he said.
“The diversity not only of voices and faces, but also of the diversity of stories is going to suffer.”